American Government and Politics

Who Will Defend Democracy? Evaluating Tradeoffs in Candidate Support Among Partisan Donors and Voters

Brendan Nyhan Dartmouth College
Gretchen Helmke University of Rochester
Mitchell Sanders Bright Line Watch
Katherine Clayton Dartmouth College
John Carey Dartmouth College
Susan Stokes University of Chicago
Scholars and pundits fear that the American public’s commitment to democracy is declining and that citizens are willing to embrace candidates who would trample democratic principles. We examine whether violations of democratic principles generate resistance from voters and top campaign donors and whether such resistance extends across partisan lines. In a conjoint survey experiment, we investigate how regular citizens and donor elites trade off partisanship, policy positions, and democratic values when choosing between hypothetical political candidates. Our findings indicate that both citizens and donors punish violations of democratic principles irrespective of party. However, we find partisan polarization (especially among donors) in the effects of candidates supporting voter identification laws that threaten access to the franchise. These results suggest that the public and donors may sometimes be willing to forgive transgressions against democratic norms that align with their partisan and policy preferences.
Summary of changes from Version 1
Updated September 19, 2019