American Government and Politics

American Government and Politics

The Dimensionality of Cosponsorship Behavior in the House of Representatives

Andres Carrizosa Author ORCID home | opens in new tab Rice University
Abstract
Legislative stability exists in the House of Representatives, but there is not a consensus on whether this stability is produced by a Preference Induced Equilibrium (PIE), which predict that if preferences are unidimensional an equilibrium can be found at the position of the median legislator, or a Structure Induced Equilibrium (SIE), which predicts that multidimensional legislative preferences must be constrained by institutions to produce stable outcomes. While both explanations predict that roll-call behavior will be unidimensional, they make competing predictions for less constrained behavior such as cosponsorship behavior. By relying on Bayesian item-response methods that allow for the assessment of dimensionality of both cosponsorship behavior and roll-call behavior on a comparable scale--which has been problematic in the past--I provide evidence in support of a SIE in the House. While roll-call behavior is unidimensional, only around 30% of cosponsorship behavior is explained by the first dimension of legislative preferences.
Summary of changes from Version 1
I have included more analysis about what including a second dimension is useful for. What can multidimensional models capture about legislative behavior that cannot be captured by unidimensional models? I explore this additional question.
Content
Thumbnail image of content item
Supplementary material
Thumbnail image of content item
Appendix: The Dimensionality of Cosponsorship Behavior in the House of Representatives
Appendix, which includes summaries of data, formulas of indexes, and additional diagnostic statistics.
Comments
Log in using your APSA account or Register to comment
Comments are not moderated before they are posted, but they can be removed by the site moderators if they are found to be in contravention of our Commenting Policy – please read this policy before you post. Comments should be used for scholarly discussion of the content in question. You can find more information about how to use the commenting feature here .
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.